Castleman: To Level the Playing Field in College Completion: Invest in Advising

According to new research from Batten's Benjamin Castleman and Texas A&M University's Andrew Barr, intensive college advising leads to large increases in the share of low-income high school seniors that earn their bachelor's degree.

Students testing in classroom, Ben Castleman,  Andrew Barr, College Completion and Advising

The scaled-back version of president Biden’s signature Build Back Better plan only heightens the importance of investing limited resources in evidence-based strategies. Our research suggests that college advising models can close the gap in degree attainment between academically-prepared students from the bottom and top quartile of family income and substantially reduce racial gaps.

In a new working paper released Thursday, we show that intensive college advising leads to large increases in the share of low-income high school seniors that earn their bachelor’s degree.

The college advising program we study, “Bottom Line,” operates in several cities across the U.S.; prior to the start of senior year in high school, we worked with Bottom Line to randomly assign applicants to the program to either receive Bottom Line advising or to a control group that did not get advising from Bottom Line, but who were free to access other college advising supports in their schools or communities.

Students randomly assigned to Bottom Line were 16 percent more likely than control group students to earn a bachelor’s degree within five years.


Read in The Hill

Related News

Explore The Latest
News and Information

  • UVA Batten community members tapped for University strategic planning committee
    Renee Grutzik
    UVA Batten community members tapped for University strategic planning committee
    UVA Batten MPP student Imane Akhanous and associate professor of public policy, Andy Pennock, were selected to serve on President Beardsley's new committee tasked with developing a long-term strategic plan for the University.
    Learn More
  • UVA Batten dean to lead Rockefeller Brothers Fund as next president and CEO
    Renee Grutzik
    UVA Batten dean to lead Rockefeller Brothers Fund as next president and CEO
    Ian Solomon, dean of the University of Virginia’s Batten School of Leadership and Public Policy, announced Tuesday that he will step down, effective Aug. 2.
    Learn More
  • Celebrating the UVA Batten Class of 2026
    Student Stories
    Celebrating the UVA Batten Class of 2026
    On May 16, UVA Batten celebrated the graduation of 199 students who earned Bachelor of Arts or Master of Public Policy degrees in 2026.
    Learn More