Workhorses, not show horses: Five ways to promote effective lawmaking in Congress

Craig Volden, professor at the Frank Batten School of Leadership and Public Policy and Co-Director of the Center for Effective Lawmaking, writes in The Conversation that there are ways to get things done under the U.S. Capitol dome.

US CapitolAmericans dislike Congress, especially when it fails to act on pressing problems. They are then surprised by legislative accomplishments on climate change, gun control and maintaining competitiveness with China.

But Congress does much more on a daily basis than deal – or fail to deal – with high-profile issues.

We have spent more than a decade exploring the thousands of bills and hundreds of laws produced by members of Congress each year. We find that individual representatives and senators vary dramatically in how interested they are in lawmaking and how effectively they advance their proposals. And we see opportunities to build a better Congress.

We have devised and generated a “Legislative Effectiveness Score” for each member of the House and Senate for each two-year Congress for the past 50 years. These scores are based on 15 metrics, capturing how many bills each lawmaker sponsors, how far they progress toward law and how substantively significant they are. The scores are politically neutral, with members of both parties scoring higher upon advancing whatever policies they think are best.

Voters can use these scores to see how their political representatives have fared in this measure, perhaps finding them among the 23% of representatives or 19% of senators who were highly effective in the most recently completed Congress. And researchers use them to determine the factors that make lawmakers effective in Congress.

Based on our work, we have identified five ways that legislators, reformers and voters can help promote effective lawmaking in Congress.

Related News

Explore The Latest
News and Information

  • Q&A: How are data and AI changing the future of policymaking?
    Q&A: How are data and AI changing the future of policymaking?
    Data analysis and artificial intelligence offer new ways to inform public policy, but using those tools effectively requires context and careful analysis. In this Q&A with Jay Shimshack, associate dean for academic affairs at UVA Batten, find out how the school's new Master of Science in Public Policy and Data sets graduates up for success.
    Learn More
  • Hands-on humanitarian response field training
    News
    Hands-on humanitarian response field training
    Through a four-day field training, students in Professor Kirsten Gelsdorf’s course on "Leadership in Global Disaster and Conflict" learned what it takes to engage and lead – during a humanitarian crisis.
    Learn More
  • Meet UVA Batten’s first transfer student navigator
    Student Life
    Meet UVA Batten’s first transfer student navigator
    Sean Gillaspie knows exactly what it feels like to walk into UVA Batten as a transfer student, because he did it himself just a year ago. Now, as Batten’s first transfer student navigator, he’s supporting this year’s largest-ever transfer cohort as they adjust to life on Grounds.
    Learn More